METHOD CHECK · SAN FRANCISCO · JANUARY–MAY 2025

How close do intersection-radius counts come to building-level dispatch records?

← Open the Dorsey PSH dispatch dashboard, video, transcript, and Cohen–Smuts response

The method produces very different results by building. Narrow radii often miss calls; wider radii capture substantial surrounding activity. A numerical match at a few sites does not validate building attribution across the portfolio.

This is a diagnostic comparison, not a measured accuracy rate. Public “Medical Incident” calls and the letter’s EMS category are not documented as identical. Neither dataset supplies the paired call IDs needed here to label individual proximity matches as correct or incorrect.

Related dashboard correction · October 18, 2026

John Burton Housing’s official “all incidents” row appears cumulative and was incorrectly summed in the earlier Dorsey dashboard. Its disputed combined figures are now excluded from that dashboard’s totals and rankings and from the official-dispatch map. This page’s comparison statistics use official EMS, not “all incidents,” so the numerical results here are unchanged. The PDF’s printed row still needs DEM clarification; no inferred replacement counts are used.

What was compared

The Dorsey dashboard contains the full monthly official tables, Dorsey’s June 17, 2025 video and transcript, the response timeline, and the Grand Jury connection.

The original proximity page covers June 14–September 11, 2026. The Cohen–Smuts tables stop in June 2025, so their displayed totals cannot be compared directly. This analysis reruns the same distance approach for January 1–May 31, 2025. June is excluded because the original inquiry was made June 17 and the table’s June cutoff is not explicit.

Reused the 227 mapped coordinates embedded in the original Bluoz page.
Matched 114 of the 155 official table rows by normalized site name or a reviewed name alias. These are candidate entity matches, not an independent audit of coordinates or exact official address queries.
Used 101 matched sites with numeric EMS entries in all five months and positive EMS totals for the summary diagnostic. The other 13 matched sites remain visible below.
Retrieved 76,619 unique public call numbers for the period; 76,614 had coordinates and five did not. No call number had conflicting types or coordinates in the grouped response. Public records were retrieved October 18, 2026 and may reflect later corrections.
Counted each call number once per radius per site, using straight-line great-circle distances. A call can still fall within several different sites’ circles.

Portfolio diagnostic: 101 sites

Radius	Public nearby medical counts*	Official EMS	Count ratio*	Sites with zero nearby medical	Rank correlation**
100 ft	2,906	4,573	0.64×	76/101	-0.15
250 ft	20,268	4,573	4.43×	3/101	0.17
500 ft	64,012	4,573	14.00×	0/101	0.18

*Sums of site-level proximity counts can count the same call near multiple buildings; these are not unduplicated citywide totals. Ratios are differences in observed counts, not a claim that every excess call is misclassified. **Spearman rank correlation; 1 means matching rank order, 0 means little monotonic relationship. The low correlations here do not support reliable building rankings from these radius counts.

At 100 feet, 76 of the 101 sites have zero public medical matches despite positive official EMS totals. At 250 feet, the summed nearby counts are 4.43 times the official EMS total; at 500 feet they are approximately 14 times as large. No radius is consistently close across the matched portfolio.

Four examples

Site	Mapped address	Official EMS	EMS months	Medical 100 ft	Medical 250 ft	Medical 500 ft	All public Fire/EMS 100 ft	All public Fire/EMS 250 ft	All public Fire/EMS 500 ft	Official fire	Fire months	Name match	Summary sample
Seneca Hotel	34 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	80	5/5	0	311	1158	0	441	1717	97	5/5	normalized name	Included
HomeRise at Mission Bay	410 China Basin Street, San Francisco, CA 94158	75	5/5	0	0	124	0	0	144	6	3/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Tahanan	833 Bryant Street, San Francisco, CA	148	5/5	144	159	307	201	224	390	55	5/5	normalized name	Included
Vera Haile	121 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94102	69	5/5	0	247	1278	0	291	1624	9	5/5	reviewed name alias	Included

Seneca and HomeRise illustrate missed nearby counts at small radii. Seneca and Vera Haile illustrate large surrounding-area counts at wider radii. Tahanan’s 144 medical calls within 100 feet are numerically close to its 148 official EMS calls, but aggregate proximity does not establish that they are the same incidents.

Why a building call can disappear from a 100-foot search

A call originating inside a building can be displayed publicly at a nearby intersection or call-box location more than 100 feet from the building’s mapped point. A radius search measures distance to that published point, not necessarily to the original incident address. It can therefore miss a real building call.

This is why “zero public medical matches within 100 feet” does not mean “zero EMS calls at the building.” Conversely, a dot near a building does not prove that the call originated there. Increasing the radius may recover displaced calls while also including calls from neighboring properties and streets.

The 76-of-101 result demonstrates disagreement between the radius counts and the official address-level EMS totals; it does not establish the original address of any particular public call or prove that location masking accounts for every difference. Site-coordinate placement and differences between public “Medical Incident” and official EMS categories can also contribute.

How to verify individual calls: obtain an address-specific DEM dispatch list for the same period, then match it to public records using a shared CAD/call or incident number. If shared identifiers are unavailable, date, time, call type and nearby location can support candidate matches, with uncertainty retained. The monthly Cohen–Smuts tables do not contain individual timestamps or call identifiers, so they cannot perform that verification. A one-month Seneca pilot would be a practical starting point.

Interpretation

The original proximity page remains useful as a view of emergency activity near service sites. This test does not support relabeling its circles as calls originating at those buildings. Public location masking, site-coordinate placement, neighborhood activity and overlapping circles can all affect the result; this comparison cannot isolate their individual contributions.

The public Fire/EMS dataset does not measure police-only incidents. The official “all incidents” category includes police, so it is not a valid benchmark for public Fire/EMS totals. Official EMS and fire counts overlap; they are shown separately and are never added to manufacture a combined benchmark. Likewise, public non-medical calls are not assumed to equal the official fire category.

For a direct validation, obtain the exact address definitions and comparable incident-level identifiers, dates and service flags from DEM, then test each radius against those records. The PDF aggregates cannot establish precision, recall, false-positive rate or the percentage of building calls recovered.

All 114 candidate site matches

Site	Mapped address	Official EMS	EMS months	Medical 100 ft	Medical 250 ft	Medical 500 ft	All public Fire/EMS 100 ft	All public Fire/EMS 250 ft	All public Fire/EMS 500 ft	Official fire	Fire months	Name match	Summary sample
Tahanan	833 Bryant Street, San Francisco, CA	148	5/5	144	159	307	201	224	390	55	5/5	normalized name	Included
Richardson Apartments	365 Fulton Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	145	5/5	0	178	255	0	227	342	34	5/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Rene Cazenave Apartments	25 Essex Street, San Francisco, CA, 94105	140	5/5	0	145	192	0	172	249	25	5/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Henry Hotel	106 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	120	5/5	0	733	1217	0	1021	1636	16	5/5	normalized name	Included
Hartland Hotel	909 Geary Boulevard, San Francisco, CA, 94109	110	5/5	93	264	829	115	315	1025	17	5/5	normalized name	Included
Civic Center Residence	44 McAllister Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	100	5/5	0	163	1043	0	233	1282	53	5/5	normalized name	Included
Arlington Residence	480 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	97	5/5	0	273	1393	0	396	1787	14	5/5	normalized name	Included
Le Nain Hotel	730 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	94	5/5	0	242	440	0	313	620	22	3/5	normalized name	Included
Empress	144 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	90	5/5	0	323	1112	0	406	1414	25	5/5	normalized name	Included
Mission Creek Senior Community	225 Berry Street, San Francisco, CA, 94158	87	5/5	0	0	199	0	0	244	11	5/5	normalized name	Included
Crosby Hotel	516 O'Farrell Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	85	5/5	0	204	900	0	247	1163	24	5/5	normalized name	Included
Plaza Apartments	988 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	84	5/5	0	310	639	0	442	849	26	5/5	normalized name	Included
Seneca Hotel	34 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	80	5/5	0	311	1158	0	441	1717	97	5/5	normalized name	Included
The Margot	1321 Mission Street, San Francisco, CA 94103	80	5/5	95	236	477	146	307	620	44	5/5	normalized name	Included
Mission Hotel	520 S Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94110	77	5/5	0	177	350	0	219	432	13	5/5	normalized name	Included
Dalt Hotel	34 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	76	5/5	0	183	1297	0	243	1748	34	5/5	normalized name	Included
HomeRise at Mission Bay	410 China Basin Street, San Francisco, CA 94158	75	5/5	0	0	124	0	0	144	6	3/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Stanford Hotel	250 Kearny Street, San Francisco, CA, 94108	75	5/5	0	90	121	0	108	155	7	4/5	normalized name	Included
Vera Haile	121 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94102	69	5/5	0	247	1278	0	291	1624	9	5/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Bayanihan House	88 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	68	5/5	0	559	1044	0	813	1462	6	5/5	normalized name	Included
990 Polk	990 Polk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	67	5/5	0	172	841	0	215	1028	9	4/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Windsor Hotel	238 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	67	5/5	0	316	1339	0	393	1705	5	3/5	normalized name	Included
Kelly Cullen Community	220 Golden Gate Avenue San Francisco, CA, 94102	66	5/5	0	346	822	0	448	1094	15	5/5	normalized name	Included
Alder Hotel	175 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	63	5/5	172	310	1152	239	442	1597	33	5/5	normalized name	Included
City Gardens	333 12th Street, San Francisco CA 94103	60	5/5	0	75	127	0	90	170	8	5/5	normalized name	Included
Hamlin Hotel	385 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	60	5/5	0	499	1297	0	609	1722	17	4/5	normalized name	Included
Treasure Island Maceo May	1432 Halibut Court, San Francisco CA 94130	60	5/5	0	4	10	0	4	13	8	3/5	normalized name	Included
Coronet Senior Housing	3575 Geary Boulevard, San Francisco, CA, 94118	58	5/5	0	64	91	0	86	119	18	5/5	normalized name	Included
Dr. Davis Senior Community	1751 Carroll Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94124	58	5/5	0	0	80	0	0	99	8	5/5	normalized name	Included
Canon Kip Community House	705 Natoma Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	56	5/5	0	207	498	0	256	716	19	5/5	normalized name	Included
Post Hotel	589 Post Street, San Francisco, CA 94102	55	5/5	67	94	216	84	117	320	15	5/5	normalized name	Included
Winton Hotel	445 O'Farrell Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	54	5/5	0	98	748	0	118	922	6	4/5	normalized name	Included
West Hotel	141 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	52	5/5	0	323	1112	0	406	1414	10	5/5	normalized name	Included
Bishop Swing Community House	275 10th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	51	5/5	0	306	390	0	343	470	6	4/5	normalized name	Included
600 7th Street	600 7th St, San Francisco, CA 94103	47	5/5	54	63	74	69	84	107	14	5/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Edith Witt Senior Community	66 9th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	47	5/5	140	357	462	169	450	584	6	3/5	normalized name	Included
149 Mason	149 Mason Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	44	5/5	0	32	838	0	44	1040	6	2/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Auburn Hotel	481 Minna Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	44	5/5	0	346	1086	0	447	1515	9	5/5	normalized name	Included
Armstrong Place Senior Housing	5600 3rd Street, San Francisco, CA, 94124	43	5/5	52	56	64	56	62	74	2	1/5	normalized name	Included
National Hotel	1139 Market Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	43	5/5	0	186	330	0	224	386	13	3/5	normalized name	Included
Veterans Commons	150 Otis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	43	5/5	0	55	130	0	86	216	23	5/5	normalized name	Included
Diva Hotel	440 Geary Street, San Francisco, CA 94102	41	5/5	0	149	339	0	207	461	12	5/5	normalized name	Included
Edwin M. Lee	1150 3rd Street,San Francisco, CA 94158	41	5/5	69	69	222	89	89	270	11	5/5	normalized name	Included
Boyd Hotel	41 Jones Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	40	5/5	0	294	1043	0	342	1282	8	3/5	normalized name	Included
Iroquois Hotel	835 O'Farrell Street San Francisco CA 9410	40	5/5	0	132	879	0	189	1106	19	5/5	normalized name	Included
Mentone Hotel	387 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	39	5/5	267	299	1273	317	368	1557	8	4/5	normalized name	Included
Jefferson Hotel	440 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	38	5/5	0	381	1201	0	468	1586	5	2/5	normalized name	Included
Lyric Hotel	140 Jones Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	38	5/5	0	482	804	0	633	1038	18	4/5	normalized name	Included
Senator Hotel	519 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA 94109	38	5/5	0	273	1122	0	396	1485	27	5/5	normalized name	Included
Aranda Hotel	64 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	37	5/5	0	149	1186	0	200	1502	16	5/5	normalized name	Included
Graystone Hotel	66 Geary Boulevard, San Francisco, CA, 94108	37	5/5	0	12	104	0	18	134	5	3/5	normalized name	Included
William Penn Hotel	160 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	37	5/5	0	316	915	0	393	1155	6	3/5	normalized name	Included
Granada Hotel	1000 Sutter Street, San Francisco, CA 94109	36	5/5	0	91	379	0	146	605	17	4/5	normalized name	Included
Cambridge	473 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	35	5/5	0	273	1288	0	396	1657	39	5/5	normalized name	Included
Jazzie Collins Apartments	53 Colton Street, San Francisco, CA	35	5/5	14	56	196	26	82	308	13	4/5	normalized name	Included
McAllister Hotel	270 McAllister Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	33	5/5	0	76	234	0	105	319	16	5/5	normalized name	Included
Rose Hotel	125 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	33	5/5	0	733	1043	0	1021	1463	7	4/5	normalized name	Included
Elm Hotel	364 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	32	5/5	0	499	1361	0	609	1748	8	4/5	normalized name	Included
Willie B. Kennedy	1239 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94115	32	5/5	0	42	168	0	56	246	4	3/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Elk Hotel	670 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	31	5/5	0	242	659	0	313	836	14	5/5	normalized name	Included
Royan Hotel	405 Valencia St, San Francisco, CA 94103	31	5/5	80	144	278	112	215	376	2	1/5	normalized name	Included
Dudley Apartments	172 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	30	5/5	0	360	1527	0	503	2050	5	3/5	normalized name	Included
Union Hotel	811 Geary Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	30	5/5	0	151	714	0	203	903	4	4/5	normalized name	Included
Altamont Hotel	3048 16th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	29	5/5	278	293	564	352	367	704	5	3/5	normalized name	Included
Fairfax Hotel	420 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	29	5/5	0	381	1201	0	468	1586	3	2/5	normalized name	Included
Raman Hotel	1011 Howard Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	29	5/5	0	247	496	0	337	675	3	3/5	normalized name	Included
Hillsdale Hotel	51 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	28	5/5	0	311	1158	0	441	1717	5	2/5	normalized name	Included
Parkview Terrace	871 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA	26	5/5	0	42	213	0	64	312	12	4/5	normalized name	Included
Ritz Hotel	216 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	26	5/5	34	316	962	49	393	1184	21	5/5	normalized name	Included
Vincent Hotel	459 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	25	5/5	0	41	272	0	62	369	9	4/5	normalized name	Included
Camelot Hotel	124 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	24	5/5	0	187	1161	0	243	1603	9	4/5	normalized name	Included
San Cristina	1000 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94102	24	5/5	0	111	1236	0	246	1663	3	3/5	normalized name	Included
Arnett Watson Apartments	650 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	23	5/5	0	90	649	0	108	828	10	4/5	normalized name	Included
Minna Lee Hotel	149 6th Street, San Francisco, CA 94103	23	5/5	0	346	1093	0	447	1524	1	1/5	normalized name	Included
Pierre Hotel	540 Jones Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	23	5/5	0	351	658	0	460	835	2	1/5	normalized name	Included
Casa de la Misión	3001 24th Street, San Francisco, CA 94110	22	5/5	40	42	69	56	58	89	1	1/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Garland Hotel	505 O'Farrell St, San Francisco, CA 94102	22	5/5	204	225	825	247	284	1060	4	2/5	normalized name	Included
Verona Hotel	317 Leavenworth Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	22	5/5	369	381	1059	448	468	1386	—	0/5	normalized name	Included
1180 4TH ST	1180 4th Street, San Francisco, CA 94158	21	5/5	0	5	51	0	5	66	8	4/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Broadway Sansome Apartments	255 Broadway Street, San Francisco, CA, 94133	21	5/5	0	29	41	0	35	55	—	0/5	normalized name	Included
Edgeworth Hotel	770 O'Farrell Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	21	5/5	0	243	860	0	300	1078	1	1/5	normalized name	Included
Mary Helen Rogers Senior Community	701 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94102	21	5/5	27	65	197	41	91	288	11	5/5	normalized name	Included
Midori Hotel	240 Hyde Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	21	5/5	0	295	988	0	370	1270	5	3/5	normalized name	Included
735 Davis Senior	735 Davis Street, San Francsico, CA 94111	20	5/5	0	23	52	0	31	89	3	1/5	normalized name	Included
Bayview Hill Gardens	1075 Le Conte Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94124	20	5/5	0	22	27	0	30	43	4	3/5	normalized name	Included
Essex Hotel	684 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	20	5/5	224	296	848	261	358	1075	13	4/5	normalized name	Included
Veterans Academy	1030 Girard Road, San Francisco, CA, 94129	20	5/5	0	29	30	0	45	46	6	3/5	normalized name	Included
Knox Apartments	241 6th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	19	5/5	59	62	452	73	82	627	2	2/5	normalized name	Included
Railton	242 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	18	5/5	0	331	1024	0	454	1326	1	1/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Allen Hotel	1693 Market Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	17	5/5	0	92	230	0	130	338	7	4/5	normalized name	Included
Crown Hotel	528 Valencia Street, San Francisco, CA, 94110	17	5/5	0	74	286	0	91	374	5	4/5	normalized name	Included
Coronado Hotel	373 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	16	4/5	0	291	1273	0	355	1557	7	5/5	normalized name	Excluded
All Star Hotel	2791 16th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	14	5/5	0	93	93	0	136	136	14	5/5	normalized name	Included
Mary Elizabeth Inn	1040 Bush Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	14	5/5	0	31	123	0	42	206	5	4/5	normalized name	Included
Zygmunt Arendt House	850 Broderick Street, San Francisco, CA, 94115	14	5/5	18	18	43	29	29	62	6	3/5	normalized name	Included
John Burton Housing	800 Presidio Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94115	13	5/5	20	20	32	23	23	43	1	1/5	reviewed name alias	Included
Pacific Bay Inn	520 Jones Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	13	5/5	0	297	934	0	357	1174	7	4/5	normalized name	Included
Artmar Hotel	433 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA 94102	12	5/5	0	409	1423	0	496	1806	2	1/5	normalized name	Included
Hotel Isabel	1095 Mission Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	12	5/5	86	134	457	101	169	563	4	2/5	normalized name	Included
Mayfair Hotel	626 Polk Street, San Francisco, CA, 94102	12	3/5	0	120	388	0	147	524	3	3/5	normalized name	Excluded
Star Hotel	2176 Mission Street, San Francisco, CA, 94110	12	5/5	0	55	134	0	79	197	5	4/5	normalized name	Included
Eddy Street Apartments	425 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	11	4/5	0	381	1222	0	468	1588	7	3/5	normalized name	Excluded
321 Turk	321 Turk Street, San Francisco, CA 94102	10	3/5	0	155	1045	0	213	1331	—	0/5	reviewed name alias	Excluded
Aarti Hotel	391 Leavenworth St, San Francisco, CA 94102	8	5/5	273	319	997	396	457	1319	4	3/5	normalized name	Included
Edward II	3155 Scott Street , San Francisco, CA, 94123	8	5/5	27	33	57	29	38	70	—	0/5	normalized name	Included
Casa Quezada	35 Woodward Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	5	4/5	0	195	307	0	253	419	2	2/5	normalized name	Excluded
Rita de Cascia	1652 Eddy Street, San Francisco, CA 94115	3	2/5	0	16	101	0	22	143	3	2/5	normalized name	Excluded
Ellis Street Apartments	864 Ellis Street, San Francisco, CA, 94109	2	2/5	0	45	532	0	54	726	3	3/5	normalized name	Excluded
El Dorado	150 9th Street, San Francisco, CA, 94103	1	1/5	7	26	326	16	42	424	—	0/5	normalized name	Excluded
1100 Ocean Ave	1100 Ocean Avenue, San Francisco, CA, 94112	—	0/5	0	57	134	0	66	158	—	0/5	reviewed name alias	Excluded
Eddy and Taylor	210 Taylor Street, San Francisco, CA 94102	—	0/5	0	411	766	0	505	955	—	0/5	normalized name	Excluded
Island Bay Homes	Multiple Sites	—	0/5	29	31	89	39	43	123	—	0/5	normalized name	Excluded
Kinney Hotel	410 Eddy Street	—	0/5	46	381	1201	61	468	1586	—	0/5	normalized name	Excluded
Monterey Boulevard Apartments	403 Monterey Boulevard, San Francisco, CA 94127	—	0/5	4	5	13	5	8	16	—	0/5	normalized name	Excluded

Blank official months are excluded from sums, not converted to zero. Only sites with five numeric EMS months and a positive total contribute to the summary. Rows are sorted by official recorded EMS count.

Unmatched official site names (41)

1036 Mission; 1064-66 Mission; 10th and Mission; 1178 Folsom; 1296 Shotwell; 180 Jones; 1950 Mission; 270 Turk; 383 6th Avenue; 455 Fell Street; 5th Street Apartments; 626 Mission Bay; 681 Florida; 835 Turk; 95 Laguna Senior Housing; Abigail Hotel; Ambassador Hotel; Apollo Hotel; Baldwin; Bristol Hotel; Cadillac Hotel; Caldrake Arms Hotel; Canon Barcus Community House; Casa Adelante; Casa Colibri; Casa Esperanza; Cecil Williams; Curran House; Curry Senior Center; Felton Institute; Folsom/Dore; Franciscan Towers; Hazel Betsey; Juan Pifarre Plaza; Looper; Mosaica; Richardson Hall; South Park Residence - Gran Oriente; South Park Residence - Hotel Madrid; South Park Residence - Park View; Star View Court

Sources and reproducibility

Original 2026 proximity analysis and mapped site coordinates.
DataSF Fire Department and Emergency Medical Services Dispatched Calls for Service, API dataset nuek-vuh3. Query: call_date >= 2025-01-01 and < 2025-06-01; select and group by call_number, call_type, case_location; limit 300000; order by call_number. Returned 76619 groups, below the limit. Deduplicated by call_number and excluded missing/conflicting locations. Medical means call_type exactly “Medical Incident.”
Cohen–Smuts response, July 2, 2025: context PDF pages 41–44; EMS 49–50; fire 51–52. Monthly numeric values transcribed from the supplied PDF. Table has 155 rows/category although letter says 156 sites.

Normalized matching removes punctuation and the generic terms hotel, apartments and residence. Fourteen additional matches use reviewed name variants, displayed in the CSV. No fuzzy match was automatically accepted. A matched name does not certify the historical operator, mapped coordinate, or full address used by DEM. Coordinates were not relocated to improve agreement.

The embedded download includes all radius counts, source pages, official monthly coverage and both site-name variants. All computed values are embedded; no live API is needed to open this report.